One of the most common questions we hear from separating couples is:
“If we’re in mediation, do we really need lawyers too?”

It’s a fair question. Mediation is already designed to be a more affordable, cooperative alternative to court. So adding a lawyer can feel counterintuitive - like bringing a referee to a conversation that’s supposed to be collaborative.

But here’s the truth: while hiring a lawyer does come with an added cost, it’s often a small investment compared to the price of delay, confusion, or unresolved conflict. And more importantly, the role of a lawyer in mediation is not the same as it is in court.

Let’s unpack this.

Mediation Is Built to Be Cost-Effective. Even With Lawyers.

The average cost of litigating a divorce in Ontario ranges anywhere from $20,000–$80,000 per person depending on complexity. The price tag grows quickly with lawyer letters, motions, delays, and court appearances. Even “simple” cases can stretch into months - or years - of legal back-and-forth.

Mediation, on the other hand, often stays in the range of $4,000–$7,000 per couple. Even with a few hours of lawyer input along the way, the total cost is still significantly lower than litigation.

So yes, engaging a lawyer in mediation does add an expense - but it’s not even in the same ballpark as going to court. And unlike court, you control how much or how little you spend. Many people consult a lawyer once or twice during key decision points, and nothing more.

And if cost is your concern, there are ways to make sure that the legal advice you do seek is efficient and well-targeted. We’ve written more about that here: Lower the Cost of Divorce: What to Tell Your Family Lawyer. It’s a helpful read if you’re wondering how to use legal advice wisely - without letting it take over the process.

When Might It Make Sense to Bring a Lawyer Into Mediation?

Mediation is built to help you work through the entire separation process: parenting decisions, support, division of property and debt, and your long-term financial plan. But it’s normal to hit a point where one or both of you feels uncertain. Maybe something in the proposal doesn’t sit right. Maybe there’s a disagreement neither of you can bridge on your own.

This is often where a lawyer can help - not to escalate, but to clarify.

Here are some common moments where lawyer support can make a difference:

• Reality checks: Sometimes a client wants a sanity check - "Am I being fair?" "Am I giving up too much?"
• Moments of doubt or standstill: A lawyer can offer clarity on legal options if one person feels frozen or unsure about the implications.
• Reviewing agreements: Once your separation agreement is drafted, most people want their own lawyer to look it over before signing.
• Pressure points: If there’s a power imbalance or emotional difficulty that’s clouding decision-making, legal advice can empower better choices.

Lawyers in Mediation Are More Flexible, Creative, and Focused on Solutions

Here’s something many people don’t know: lawyers in court are bound by rigid rules and often locked into an adversarial role, arguing for you and against the other person. In mediation,that pressure drops. Lawyers can be creative, supportive, and practical - just like you need them to be; and when paired with practical negotiation tools like active listening, reframing, and reality testing, this support can be especially powerful.

And when lawyers understand the mediation process (as many do), they become valuable allies in moving things forward - not obstacles. They can:

• Help you reframe a settlement proposal
• Offer guidance without “taking over”
• Communicate directly with your mediator if you need them to
• Work in the background, as needed- not on a full retainer

This flexible role keeps the process focused, efficient, and far more affordable.

Is It Mandatory to Have a Lawyer?

Not at all.

Many of our clients move through mediation without ever hiring a lawyer. Others choose to consult one at key moments. And some retain a lawyer from the start but make it clear: this is a mediation, not a litigation. You get to decide how much or how little legal support you need.

That said, we always recommend that you obtain independent legal advice (ILA) before signing a final agreement. Not because we think your agreement will fall apart -but because it’s one of the best ways to ensure that your choices are informed, durable, and legally sound.

Having a lawyer doesn’t mean you’re heading to court. It doesn’t mean you’re trying to “win.” It just means you’re taking the time to double-check your understanding - and giving yourself peace of mind.

If you’re feeling unsure or need extra support at a particular moment, a lawyer can help you sort through your concerns and bring clarity. Then you return to the mediation table more grounded, focused, and ready to move ahead.

Mediation Is Still the Hub

Think of mediation as your home base.

At Family Mediation Group, mediation remains the core process. We guide families through financial disclosure, parenting plans, support calculations, property division, and everything else that needs to be addressed to separate fully and fairly. It’s a comprehensive approach - one that saves time, reduces stress, and gives you more control.

But if, along the way, one or both of you needs legal input - just for a few hours - it doesn’t mean you’ve failed. It means you’re being thoughtful and intentional. It means you’re protecting what matters while still avoiding the escalation, expense, and uncertainty of court.

So if you’re wondering whether a lawyer is “worth it” in mediation, ask yourself:
Will it help me feel more confident?
Will it help us move forward with less conflict?
Will it help avoid the spiral into court?

If the answer is yes - even once - then that may be the best kind of help to say yes to.

And as always, we’re here to help you navigate the process, connect you with professionals who understand mediation, and guide you toward resolution - on your terms. We’re here to help you build a path that works for you - not just for the system.

If you’re not sure whether your lawyer is the right fit for a mediation process, you might want to read this: What Is Your Lawyer Telling You About Mediation?. It explores how to tell whether your lawyer is truly supporting your goals - or subtly steering you toward court.

‍